Over on Publishing Perspectives today, I'm asking a perhaps radical (and yes, of course, naive) question: What would happen if we stopped labeling books, YA or otherwise? It's a notion I've bandied about in my head for a while now—one that seems extraordinarily relevant as we consider the very notion of crossover books, classic books, and the role that labels have or have not played. From the essay:
Crossover books. Classic books. Aren’t they, at the very least, kissing cousins? And aren’t they also the books whose labels have been systematically sidestepped or blatantly ignored, whose labels, in the end, made no perceivable difference, save for the various honors and awards for which the books qualified? This conspicuous refusal to stay within the reading lines has represented, I think we can all agree, excellent good news for the books themselves, and excellent good news for readers.The whole can be found here.
What, then, does all this suggest about a label’s utility? What, indeed, would happen if the “young adult” label suddenly (in fantastical, whimsical, utterly surreal fashion) vanished? Certainly the YA label is not “protecting” teens from scandalous reads (however readers choose to define scandalous these days); it’s not the equivalent, in other words, of a PG rating. And certainly the YA label doesn’t tell us much of anything about the story we’re about to encounter, or about its relative artistry. “YA” tells us only that a teen or teens is involved. But so what, really, because at the end of the day, that’s the case for many an adult novel, too.
In the meantime, while I was posting this, I received word that Kirkus named Small Damages the recommended teen book of the week.
My head happily spins.
3 Comments on What makes for a classic book, and what is the utility of the YA label? I ask those questions at Publishing Perspectives, last added: 7/19/2012
Display Comments
Add a Comment
The good news for Small Damages just keeps rolling in! Congrats so many times over!
I've always said a good book is a good book, period. If I were still a child, though, I'd want to know there were books out there just for me (not that I couldn't step outside and read other things). For me, there's something warm and fuzzy in claiming a genre.
Hi Beth,
Thank you so much for saying what I've been complaining to friends and family for at least over a year! It finally worked had me work up the courage to tackle this controversial topic on my blog. I mentioned and linked to this post in my post. I hope you don't mind!
Amanda
http://www.hippiesbeautyandbooksohmy.com/2012/07/opinion-should-we-drop-ya-label.html