Let's Take the Long Way Home, Gail Caldwell's classic and classically beautiful memoir of friendship, hit me deeply
when I first read it. It is a dignified book, a true story of loss. Caldwell had written of her friend, the writer Caroline Knapp, who had fought off anorexia and alcoholism by the time the two met, and who had shared, with Caldwell, a love of rivers and of dogs. Caldwell had written of Knapp's dying, from lung cancer, just as Knapp's life was finally making sense. Personal happiness and calm had been found. A door had opened. Cancer slammed it shut.
Caldwell's memoir left me with a lingering desire to know more about Caroline Knapp, and yesterday I finally read
Drinking: A Love Story, the famously famous memoir about Knapp's slide into and recovery from alcoholism. I'm not sure why I had avoided this book for so long. I'm not sure what I thought it would be. But what I discovered, in
Drinking, was an immeasurably intelligent and quiet voice. I found a woman I am sure I would have liked.
There isn't the bravado, in
Drinking, of the Big Survivor. There isn't the boast one sometimes hears in the recounting of harrowing tales—
Can you believe I was like that? Can you imagine I survived? I know it's nasty, I know I was a jerk, but secretly, really, wasn't it all kind of wondrous, in a twisted (I'll admit it) way? There isn't the sense that Knapp believes her story trumps all other tales. There is only the sense that perhaps by telling her tale—by exploring the slide, the massive deceptions, the dangers, the heat and seeming loveliness of alcohol, the balm of community—she may be helpful to others. This is not memoir as exorcism or exhibitionism, in other words. It's not a memoir in which the rememberer pretends to remember any more than she does. It's a book that is moving and hopeful and sad. It's impact, on me, will forever linger.
I returned to Caldwell's memoir after finishing
Drinking. I read again those opening pages. I understood—it was even clearer now—the size of Caldwell's loss.
Dignity is a word I have long associated with Darin Strauss. His refined mind and sensibilities were on display in novels like
Chang and Eng. A certain quietude pervaded interviews. When I learned that Strauss was sending a memoir into the world, a memoir entrusted to McSweeney's (and hence, in some fashion, to the multiply talented and deeply generous Dave Eggers), I knew for certain what I'd be reading next.
I read
Half a Life this morning, grateful for every white-steeped page. It is, as you must have heard by now, the story of an accidental death—the story of what happened one day when Strauss set out to play some "putt putt" with his high school friends. He was 18, behind the wheel of his father's Oldsmobile. On the margin of the road, two cyclists pedaled forward. Of a sudden, there was a zag, a knock, an "hysterical windshield." A cyclist, a girl from Strauss's school, lay dying on the road. She'd crossed two lanes of highway to reach Strauss's car. He braked, incapable of forestalling consequences.
It was forever. It was always. A girl had died. A boy had lived. Strauss spent his college years, his twenties, his early thirties incapable of reconciling himself to the facts, of entrusting them to friends. There's much he can't remember perfectly. There are gaps, white space, breakage—all of which, in this McSweeney's production, is rendered with utmost decency—the thoughts broken into small segments, big breaths (blank pages) taken in between. There is knowing here, not shouting. There is an exploration of guilt, and no bravado.
Half a Life sits now, on my shelf, beside Gail Caldwell's
Let's Take the Long Way Home—two memoirs that transcend precisely because they are so quiet, so well considered, so honorable. These books, along with Rahna Reiko Rizzuto's
Hiroshima in the Morning, give me hope that memoir, the form, is finding its center again. There may not be any sure-fired truths, but there are consequences. There may be stories, but they are always tangled. There may be ache, but there is solace, too. There may be drama, but in drama's wake, we stand. In need of understanding. In need of one another.
If there was ever a book I wanted the moment I heard of its existence, it was this one.
If there was ever a book that conformed to my abstract idealization of it, it was, again, this one—Gail Caldwell's finely crafted, thoroughly beautiful, absolutely heartbreaking
Let's Take the Long Way Home. This is, of course, the story of Caldwell's dear friendship with the writer Caroline Knapp—the story of long walks taken with beloved dogs, of the glass face of rowed-upon water, of pasts and imperfections and desires entrusted, one to the other, of a cancer diagnosis and of a death, Caroline Knapp's, when she was at the prime of her life and the center, in so many ways, of Caldwell's world.
Home is a memoir filled with perfectly wrought particulars: "I often went out in early evening, when the wildlife had settled and the shoreline had gone from harsh brightness to Monet's gloaming, and then I would row back to the dock in golden light, the other scullers moving like fireflies across the water." But it is also a memoir so wise and teaching, so fundamentally
true ("...it was possible to walk through fear and come out scorched but breathing"
) that it occurrs to me that anyone who has ever suffered loss—which is to say anyone at all—should buy this book and keep it near for all the wisdom it has to offer.
For that is what
Home has most abundantly to offer—hard, lived-in wisdom for souls who lose and hearts that break.
Home is not a tale about how Caldwell survived the loss of her best friend, though Caldwell has survived. It is instead both instruction and allegory on the power of kindness and small gestures, the fidelity of friendship and memory, the tenacity and tenuousness that make us our own complicated people in need of other complicated people. Caroline Knapp is no longer here; she isn't. But because Caldwell has written such an exquisite book, she can now be found, by all of us, in the bright, ephemeral gloaming.
Hi Beth - I found your site while searching for anything recent on Gail Caldwell. I had just finished reading her memoir, having read Caroline's years before, and wanted to connect with someone about it. I am stuck in my chair by the grief and beauty of that book. Really: I have things to do, but can't seem to move.
On a peppier note, I also received a PW starred review recently. It was the highlight of my writing career. I wish there was some kind of physical token of such an honor - a graduation cord or even a t-shirt that says: STARRED.
I think I'll go try to follow you on Twitter or FB. Then get the hell out of this chair.
Susan Kushner Resnick
@suekush, susankushnerresnick.com
YOU SAVED ME, TOO