How to use this Page

This is how we can have a rational conversation about health insurance. Ask yourself and everyone you know three questions:

1. What percentage of your annual income do you spend on health care costs?*
2. How many people does that cover?
3. What do you think is a reasonable percentage?

My husband and I (both self-employed) spend about 20% of our income on health insurance and medical costs. How about you?

Edward A. Zelinsky is the Morris and Annie Trachman Professor of Law at the Benjamin N. Cardozo School of Law of Yeshiva University. He is the author of The Origins of the Ownership Society: How The Defined Contribution Paradigm Changed America. In this article, Professor Zelinsky criticizes New York’s “convenience of the employer” doctrine for double taxing telecommuters at a time when public policy should be encouraging, rather than hindering, telecommuting. He calls on Congress to pass the Telecommuter Tax Fairness Act to stop such double taxation. Read his past OUPblog posts here.

A gallon of gas today costs $4.00 or more in most parts of the country. The public is concerned, as perhaps never before, about the impact of human activity on the global environment. In this setting, telecommuting has emerged as an environmentally sensitive and economically sensible lifestyle.
By permitting individuals to work at home for part (often much) of the work week, telecommuting removes telecommuters’ cars from the roads, thereby reducing traffic congestion, gas consumption, and automotive pollution. Telecommuting from home also opens job opportunities for persons for whom a conventional, daily trip to the work place is difficult or undesirable – parents’ of small children, disabled individuals, persons who live far from major employment centers. Telecommuting allows employers to hire these individuals who might otherwise withdraw from the labor force.

For all of these reasons, public policy should encourage, or at least not hinder, the growth of telecommuting. Unfortunately, the tax policies of the State of New York discourage telecommuting by double taxing out-of-state individuals who telecommute for New York employers from their out-of-state homes. In particular, New York’s so-called “convenience of the employer” rule imposes nonresident New York income taxes on out-of-state telecommuters on the days they work at home, often hundreds – if not thousands – of miles from New York.

Consider, for example, the recent case of Mr. R. Michael Holt, a human resources compensation consultant who lives in Naples, Florida. In 1999, Mr. Holt worked at his home in Florida for the New York offices of KPMG, LLP and William M. Mercer, Inc. Under the employer convenience rule, New York imposed nonresident income taxes upon Mr. Holt for the income he earned working at home in the Sunshine State, thousands of miles from New York.

When the state in which a telecommuter lives also imposes an income tax, the result of New York’s tax policy is double taxation as the out-of-state telecommuter who works at home must pay tax both to New York and to the state in which she lives. The result is an unfair and inefficient tax penalty for telecommuting, namely, the double taxation of the income earned by the telecommuter on the days she works at her out-of-state home.

New York’s policy is bad, not only for out-of-state persons who telecommute to the Empire State, but potentially for telecommuters throughout the nation and for the employers who employ such telecommuters. If New York can get away with double taxing out-of-state telecommuters, other states will be tempted to emulate New York and likewise tax nonresident telecommuters who work at their out-of-state homes. The upshot will thus be double taxation of telecommuters nationwide when public policy should instead be supporting telecommuting.

Unfortunately, New York’s courts have refused to stop New York’s double taxation of nonresident telecommuters on the days such telecommuters work at their out-of-state homes. In Huckaby v. Tax Appeals Tribunal, New York’s highest court, by a narrow but decisive margin of 4-3, upheld New York’s income taxation of Thomas Huckaby on the days Mr. Huckaby worked at his home in Nashville, Tennessee.

Pending in Congress is legislation which would prevent New York and other states from using the “convenience of the employer” doctrine or any similar artifice to double tax nonresident telecommuters on the days they work at their out-of-state homes. The Telecommuter Tax Fairness Act has attracted bi-partisan support from members of Congress who recognize the importance of telecommuting-friendly public policy.

It is unreasonable for New York to punish telecommuting by double taxing workers who telecommute for New York employers from their out-of-state homes, particularly at a time when sound public policy should encourage telecommuting. There is, however, no sign that New York will alter its irrational “convenience of the employer” rule. Congress should accordingly adopt the Telecommuter Tax Fairness Act to eliminate the ability of New York and other states to double tax nonresident telecommuters on the days they work at their out-of-state homes.

ShareThis

In This Show: 2nd graders take social action to go on a trip to the Baltimore Aquarium Learning with real world effects Podcasts Mentioned: 100% KIDS Let me know where you are: Click on ‘Join the CLIP Frappr Map’ in the menu bar. Post a comment: Click the comment button below or leave a voice mail by clicking ‘leave me a message’ [...]

Today I have for you part one of a two part conversation with Heather Jopling author of wonderful books on same sex parents and alternative lifestyles, specifically Ryan’s Mom is Tall, Monicka’s Papa is Tall, and The Not-So-Only Child. Today my conversation with Heather focuses on the story behind the children’s books she has written [...]

On Today’s Show: Tonight’s show is part two of a three part series, which was recorded on the beautiful island of Hawaii, at the International Reading Association’s Regional Conference which was held there two weeks ago. Negotiating Spaces for Critical Literacy Social Action in a JK Classroom Upcoming Shows NOTE: Some of the audio had to be re-recorded on [...]

Author: Robin Tzannes
Illustrator: Korky Paul
Published: 2005 Oxford University Press
ISBN: 0192722697 Chapters.ca Amazon.com

Argh!!! Another fabulous book that’s out of print. I sure hope you can find this great book at your local library.

This hilarious and thought-provoking tale of greed gets squeals of delight time after time.

In This Show: A listener inspired episode. The Shakes Festival with Seven-Year-Old Lucy, Andrea and Mark Podcasts Mentioned: Just One More Book, Mostly News, Desperate Husbands AndyCast, Canadian Podcast Buffet, Electric Sky Special Thank You: Andrea and Mark, of Just One More Book and their daughter Lucy for providing material for this show. Thanks also to Charles Cadenhead [...]

On Today’s Show: A multi-media text set of children’s books and audio that focus on acts of courage and acts of kindness. Save Our School by the Children of Selsted Primary Si Se Puede, Yes We Can The Streets are Free Selavi and Radyo Timoun. IndyKids BabagaNewz Kids Can Make A Difference® (KIDS) Sage Tyrtle on Deamonte Love and schools in Louisiana [...]

On Today’s Show: Save Our School : The Children of Selsted Primary Thank You To: Jeff Wood, Shannon Blaney, Wayne Serebrin, Yvonne Siu Runyan and Celia Oyler, for commenting on the show, contacting me regarding the show, or pinning my frappr map. And I also want to thank Allyn Kurin for the station ID. Congratulations To: Jeff Wood [...]

Teachers at work Behind the Scenes : A Ramadan Story On Today’s Show: A Ramadan Story by Celia Oyler: About a student teacher who took a chance and changed school for a number of children. Thank You to: Celia Oyler , for contributing to the show, as well as Mark, Andrea, Bayla, and Lucy for the station ID. [...]

A Crossover Show with the Just One More Book Podcast on “Elbert’s Bad Word and the Social Construction of Text” On this show Elbert’s Bad Word as a focus for CLIP and Just One More Book (JOMB), JOMB promo. Click here to pop over to Andrea and Mark’s Just One More Book discussion regarding Elbert’s Bad Word, and [...]

Re-visiting Pluto and What Gets in the Way of Practicing Critical Literacy? In this show: Re-visiting Pluto’s Demotion and What gets in the way of creating spaces for critical literacy? Special Thanks To: Mitzi Lewison, Sarah VanderZanden, Amanda Vender, and Heather for commenting on the show. I also want to say thank you to Kathleen Fay for the [...]

Questioning and Researching from the Start In this show: “Pluto, I Found Him!”, Taking Social Action in 2nd Grade. Special Thanks to : Carol Felderman for contributing to the show. Participate in the show. Subscribe and listen in iTunes XML Feed Location : feed://www.bazmakaz.com/clip/?feed=rss2 Let me know where you are by clicking on ‘Join the CLIP Frappr Map’ in the menu [...]

Welcome to CLIP! In this show; introducing the podcast and 3-5 year olds take social action. Music : Little by Little by Justin Gordon and Quit My Day Job by Geoff Smith Participate in the show. Subscribe and listen in iTunes XML Feed Location : feed://www.bazmakaz.com/clip/?feed=rss2 Let me know where you are by clicking on ‘Join the CLIP Frappr [...]